Forty-five years ago, today, the Supreme Court handed down their dubious 7-2 verdict in the landmark decision Roe vs Wade. The day before, on January 21, 1973, elective abortion had only been legal in four states—Alaska, Washington, Hawaii, and New York. On January 22, 1973, elective abortion was made legal in every state. Overnight and without a vote, all state prohibitions were declared null and void. Specifically, they were ruled unconstitutional. And thanks to the simultaneous ruling in Doe vs Bolton, abortion was made legal up to the very moment of birth, so long as continued pregnancy was deemed a threat to the mother’s physical, emotional, or psychological well-being. Bernard Nathanson, the physician who co-founded the National Association for Repeal of Abortion Laws (NARAL) and spent 18 months running the busiest abortion clinic in the world had this to say of the decision:
Of course, I was pleased with Justice Harry Blackmun's abortion decisions, which were an unbelievably sweeping triumph for our cause, far broader than our 1970 victory in New York or the advances since then. I was pleased with Blackmun's conclusions, that is. I could not plumb the ethical or medical reasoning that had produced the conclusions. Our final victory had been propped up on a misreading of obstetrics, gynecology, and embryology, and that's a dangerous way to win.
What was the “misreading of obstetrics, gynecology, and embryology” that Nathanson referred to? It was Justice Blackmun’s head-scratching assertion that the medical community lacked consensus with regard to the biological beginning of human life. It didn't back then; it doesn’t today. What Blackmun should have written, according to Nathanson, is that “medicine cannot tell us whether or when [an unborn human] is a protectable life, which medicine cannot say. That is a legal and philosophical matter, one the court evaded by deciding it could not tell ’when life begins.’" Nathanson called Roe vs Wade’s statements on medicine “regrettably ill-informed.”
In 1973, the first year in which America’s new abortion free-for-all went into effect, there were 615,831 abortions reported by the Centers for Disease Control (CDC). For the next nine years, the annual abortion total increased every year. By 1979, it had more than doubled—finally peaking in 1990 at roughly 1.5 million. It would take another 23 years for the annual U.S. abortion total to fall back below one million. Though 2014 is the most current year for which “official” abortion totals are available, I’ve been projecting my own annual estimates going back to 2009—and those projections have turned out to be fairly close to the Guttmacher Instititute’s final tallies, which come two or three years down the road.
The Guttmacher Institute, which is the research and policy organization birthed by Planned Parenthood, is generally regarded as the most reliable source for nationwide abortion statistics. We can thank the state of California for giving Guttmacher that distinction. In 1998, California stopped recording and reporting annual abortion totals, which immediately made the CDC totals grossly incomplete. Maryland and New Hampshire have also ceased reporting, though their omissions have far less impact on the nationwide tally. Guttmacher’s totals, which are generally only published every three years, rely on direct queries of every known and suspected abortion provider in the country.
Until this past year, I didn’t realize how much speculation was built into Guttmacher’s U.S. abortion statistics. I thought they were actual counts of actual abortions. It turns out they’re not. In 2014, Guttmacher was only able to get counts from 58% of the abortion providers it contacted, which means their abortion totals for the remaining 42% were estimated or borrowed. Though the Guttmacher statisticians have far more data available to them in the United States than they do when making their global abortion estimates, it’s fair to wonder how much their methodology is influenced by their devotion to elective abortion. Just as the CDC numbers may be hampered by underreporting, the Guttmacher numbers may be hampered by overestimation.
To reach my own annual abortion estimates, I take the published abortion counts from every available state and compare the cumulative total to Guttmacher’s most recent data—which in this case is from 2014. To date, I have obtained 2016 abortion totals for 31 states. In 2014, the combined state-reported abortion total for these 31 states was 41% of the nationwide abortion total estimated by the Guttmacher Institute. Assuming that these 31 states make up the same percentage of U.S. abortions in 2016 as they did in 2014, we can extrapolate that approximately 892,804 U.S. abortions took place in 2016. Let's round it off to 893,000.
Last January, I estimated that 906,369 U.S. abortions occurred in 2015. As the year went on, and more states reported, the estimated total rose somewhat. With 43 states now reporting, my 2015 abortion estimate has been amended to 914,417—making the 2016 tally a reduction of 2.3%. The abortion ratio, which is a more important number, fell by 1.9%. These are modest gains for abortion-vulnerable children, but I am grateful that across the country, annual abortion totals continue to fall. That being said, I remind you again that America is not a monolith. The 2016 abortion ratio increased in Alabama, Arizona, Kentucky, Maine, Minnesota, North Dakota, Oregon, South Dakota, and Washington. For those of us who oppose abortion’s continued assault on the most innocent members of the human community, we’re still a long way from where we want to be. So if you count yourself among that number, please consider joining Abort73 as a monthly donor in 2018. Simply believing that abortion is wrong isn’t enough—not by a long shot; we must also be willing to do something about it.
Michael Spielman is the founder and director of Abort73.com. Subscribe to Michael's Substack for his latest articles and recordings. His book, Love the Least (A Lot), is available as a free download. Abort73 is part of Loxafamosity Ministries, a 501c3, Christian education corporation. If you have been helped by the information available at Abort73.com, please consider making a donation.